I get so tired of reading the stories of miracle babies. I mean, each and every baby is a miracle, from the moment of conception onwards, and when a baby survives against the odds, that is indeed a wonderful, wonderful thing. But the media, at least in this part of the world, seems obsessed with their stories. There seems to be a new one in the paper or on the news each day. And despite the fact these stories provide boundless hope and warm the heart, they also get me down.
I know why these stories are so prominent, and it because they have happy endings. And everyone loves a feel good tale. Just this week there was a story about a baby born without a pancreas, and the final line of the story went something along the lines of "she is only here because of the sheer determination of her mother". And that just makes me mad. Because I was determined as hell to get Hope here, and did all the right things for 40 plus weeks, and she's not here. And she had a pancreas. And all the other bits and pieces she needed in order for a long, happy and healthy life.
Today, there was a story of a miracle 24-weeker who spent months and months in the NICU and has thankfully just gone home with a clean bill of health. And naturally, the parents are relieved, as I'm sure they had many touch and go moments. And I am thrilled for them. I really am. They came so close to living this life. At times maybe they never appreciated just how close.
Then again, in the same paper, a woman who miraculously was able to save her seven month old son when she went in to his room at exactly the right moment to check on him during a nap. He had stopped breathing, and she got there quick enough to make sure his life could be saved. She normally didn't check on him during lunch time naps, but on this day, she did. A miracle, indeed. And now of course she is counting her blessings. And so am I. This club does not need more members. The pain of losing a healthy seven month old I'm sure would pretty much destroy a parent.
And the other night on the news, the other type of story that tugs at my heart strings and that is the one that sparks "community outrage". It was about a woman who had been sent home from hospital in early labour (just like I was) because there were no beds for her available. I'm not sure if there were beds available for me the night I went in to hospital, but it was "hospital policy" to send me home because I wasn't 4cm dilated. This poor woman had to travel home in a taxi and when she got there, she delivered her daughter inside her house. But the baby is fine. She wasn't breathing at birth, but she survived. A miracle. But people are of course still outraged, and rightly so. Because they can imagine just how bad things could have been. THINGS WERE THAT BAD FOR ME. I was sent home. And she died. I was "lucky" in that I got to go back to hospital to give birth, but we knew the outcome wasn't going to be what we had planned. We knew it was going to be catastrophic, devastating and heartbreaking. Because it was all too late. They sent me home from hospital BUT she died. She wasn't a miracle or a survivor. So my story isn't told therefore the community can't be outraged. I have to suffer in silence. Or just blog out my rage.
So where are the stories of the babies who didn't quite make it? The babies who did slip away silently from SIDS because Mum didn't go and check on them during a nap, despite the fact she normally did? The 27-weeker who didn't make it out of the NICU? The 41 week baby who beat all the odds to DIE inside a healthy mother at the end of a healthy pregnancy? Where are those stories? Why aren't they being told? Why are so many of us being kept in the dark to this ugly, secret side of parenthood?
Each one of these stories on the miracle/survivor babies has a common theme: "it is every parent's worst nightmare". And while I can only imagine what I nightmare it is to see your child sick, suffering and desperately clinging to life, as I speak to many who have had to travel this hellish road, the nightmare only seems to get worse once they are actually gone. Once you can't fight for them anymore, or watch them cling to life. Even if they were suffering, or in pain. Even if they are now at peace. Once they are gone, they are gone forever and the hole left in our hearts will never heal. The hole and the ache will remain as long as they are gone, and beyond. We will always wish for one more moment to hold them close, feel them, smell them, feed them, watch them smile, watch them grow and tell them we love them. And when they're finally gone, we can't. That is, in my opinion, when the real nightmare begins - living the rest of your life without them. Having to plan their funeral. And I suppose that comes from the fact that Hope did die in utero. That I never got a chance to fight for her. That I never got a chance to see her fight. To see her grit and determination. That she was gone before we were both given a chance.
I used to be a journalist, and I still have many contacts in the job. I have been trying tirelessly to get a story up on our babies, and the fact that things don't always go well. That nine months doesn't always end in happily ever after. But I often come up against brick walls. "Too taboo". "We don't want to scare parents." "We need there to be closure, or a happy ending." But that's the thing, there is no silver lining when a baby dies. Even if another one follows, the pain from losing the one who came before does not go away. And why does baby death have to be taboo? All sorts of other deaths are reported in the media every day. Road accident deaths, murders, skin cancer victims and the list is endless really.
In this country alone, six babies a day are stillborn. One in 140 pregnancies ends in a stillbirth. Ten times more babies are stillborn than die of SIDS. There are almost as many stillborn babies as there are breast cancer victims each year. But why did I only learn about these tragic stats after the fact? Why didn't I know this before I entered the pregnancy? Why aren't more people outraged about this? Why isn't more being done?
I want more people to know about the real risks. I want more people to know that despite being young, fit and healthy and having an easy pregnancy, it does not mean your baby will come home with you. Yes it will scare parents, but if scaring them can provide them with one small sliver of information that can get their baby over the line, and home from hospital, then that is a good thing. I would love to know that Hope's story saved one baby's life. I would love that.
I really do believe, that if I knew part of what I know now, Hope would be here. Would I have listened to that stuff or really heard the message when I was living in the happy bubble of her pregnancy? Hard to say, but if more stories were written about the "taboo" subject, maybe the message would eventually get across. This happened with SIDS 20 years ago, and as a result, far less babies now lose their lives in this tragic way. The death rate from stillbirth has remained unchanged for years. It needs to change. We need to change it.
For this pregnancy, I am being monitored far more closely than I was last time. There will be more scans and frequent monitoring in the final weeks. With Hope, there wasn't any. Just the two ultrasounds, then 30 mins on the fetal heart monitor at 40 weeks and 1 day when I went in to labour (the day I was sent home from hospital). That was it. Now, they will be doing everything they can to prevent the same tragic outcome, even though there is no increased risk of that happening again. I go in with the same odds as last time. And that isn't all that comforting, really. I beat the odds once before. Some days it is hard to believe that I wont again.
So why wasn't more done in my last pregnancy? Why wasn't everything done to keep Hope alive and ensure she came home with us? Why isn't every pregnancy treated as high risk, when it is a fact any pregnancy can end up "high risk" in a flash? I just feel as if the hospital's stance is "whoops, sorry we couldn't keep the first alive, we'll definitely make sure we try much harder this time". It isn't enough. All babies deserve this high level of care. All pregnant mothers need to know their caregivers are doing everything they can at every possible opportunity. There is no place for complacency in obstetrics and midwifery. Obstetricians and midwifes should always err on the side of caution. If this had happened with Hope, again I KNOW she would be here. She really would.
While today I feel happy for the parents of the latest miracle baby stories, I just feel sad for me. For us. As much as Hope was our miracle, and I feel blessed I got to carry her as long as I did, I just wish she could have ended up as a miracle baby story in the paper. And because she can't I want her story told anyway, as our miracle baby who tragically got away......
#MicroblogMondays: Olympic hangover
7 hours ago






Oh. My. God. I could have written this myself. And probably would have written something similar if I wasn't so concerned with real life negative stuff that can crop up b/c of my blog.
ReplyDeleteI never refer to my girls as miracles b/c I, too, believe that all babies are miracles and it drives me insane when I see others throwing around that word. And I agree with you, Hope, Abbey and all the other babies who are not with us need to have their stories told. If I had known that it could happen, I would have called the doctor the night before when something felt off. But I didn't b/c I was past my due date and bad things don't happen then.
Thank you for this post.
This is such a powerful post, and so very true.
ReplyDeleteIndeed, people only tell you after the fact that some babies die for a multitude of reasons. You are left scratching your head as nobody has referred to this up until now. Surely in this day and age, with constant media stories about daily miracles?
I never watch the news or read the paper. It is such nonsense.
Everthing you have said i couldnt agree more. I had the easiest pregnancy ever! All my family and friends were so jelous of how wonderful i made pregnancy look. But if only i had known to look out for wild movements I would have known that those crazy kicks i was watching in amazement was actually my son fighting for his life. I didnt know,i just thought "Man, does this little guy want out or what?" I remember telling my mom just that. Truth be known now he DID want out because his cord was clamped off and he was sufficating. I hate it but if only i had known about these fantic kicks (which at the time i didnt associate them with being fantic)I could have rushed to the hosiptal and maybe i too would have taken home my perfect FULL TERM baby boy.
ReplyDeleteThere was something I heard (I forgot where) where I heard about some baby who had something go wrong but "he was a fighter" and survived the whole ordeal. Well then I guess that makes my son a big wuss and decided just to give up and die because breathing was just too hard for him. I hate stuff like that. I agree with you- all babies deserve the high level of care that you get when you're "high risk". The thing is, the doctors/insurance company will say that it costs too much money to do all that monitoring, so that's why they don't do it. Yeah, because money is so much more important than not having to bury your baby. Right.
ReplyDeleteStuff like this makes me angry with the world.
I hope everything goes well with this pregnancy, and you get a good outcome this time.
xoxo
Yes. There is no place for complacency in obstetrics. The price of failure is TOO high. I'm so sorry she isn't your miracle survivor Sal. She is still a miracle and still very special. I know I will never forget her.
ReplyDeletexx
I think it's a miracle that mothers can survive the loss of a child. It's a miracle that we aren't all in psychatric hospitals after such a traumatizing experience. I'm so sorry for your loss. I'm sorry for all of our losses. I agree. All babies are miracles!
ReplyDeleteGreat post, you should have this exact post in a paper,it is so true..I spoke to the midwife at my hospital and she said that they don't mention things at the parent 6 week training night before birth and perhaps they should alert people to the fact that things go wrong, I said it should definitely be mentioned...why is it so silent...
ReplyDeleteI've experienced both.
ReplyDeleteA baby stillborn at 28 weeks for no reason.
A healthy son, who, at the age of 7 weeks, died because a virus attacked his heart. Who clung to life in the NICU for two days before the doctors decided to turn off the machines. Who died in our arms.
You're right. Every baby is a miracle. I too HATE those stories about a SPECIAL baby. A MIRACLE baby.
I often think, where's the story about Kees? Why wasn't a story written about my son? Why isn't there a story demanding an explanation for all those babies who are stillborn? Why aren't women told of the risks of stillbirth?
When the profile of SIDS was raised, and fundraising increased, research into SIDS resulted in the dramatic drop of SIDS deaths. It meant that hundreds of babies DID NOT DIE every year.
Maybe if we could focus some more research and more funds on stillbirth, more babies could be saved.
(People are still more scared of SIDS than they are of stillbirth. Yet more babies are stillborn every day.)
You are so right on the money. EVERY baby is a miracle. Of course when people like us say that we get stared at like we are crazy. And of course we are insane, what else can we be?
ReplyDeleteI love my CNM becoz she said, We'll watch you closely- EVERY woman deserves that.
I am with you hon, and lately I seem to be having this argument all too often.
ReplyDeleteI understand why people feel that pregnancy and labour have become over-medicalised; I completely get why someone would want have a home birth in water with aromatherapy candles and whale music. My problem is that as long as this taboo surrounds stillbirth and neonatal death women aren't REALLY mking an educated, informed decision.
We absolutely DO need to know the risks, we DO need to know the signs, we SHOULD be offered the frequent monitoring that you're receiving this time (and I received with Moe) regardless of our circumstances. THEN a reasonable choice can be made.
Now you've got me thinking! I feel a blog post of my own coming on, thanks Sal! x
As Louisa said, this should be the piece you submit. This should be the article people read. With love.
ReplyDeleteI hate the word "miracle" too.
ReplyDeleteEvery year our hospital does a big tv telethon to raise money for the children's wing, and they always feature the "miracle" children and babies. It makes me sick now. Especially those 24 weekers, when my 24 weeker lasted a mere 2 hours. God, this year they featured a preemie who was born at home into the toilet (supposedly mom had no idea she was pregnant) and THAT baby survived. And mine didn't. WTF.
I'd love to see that story in print. People need to know the facts.
Sal, why not give this to Nicole! I am meeting her next week to talk about the article she wants to write!!!
ReplyDeleteLove you x
I know, Sally...much love.
ReplyDeleteThanks for writing that.. I feel the same way. It's good, in some ways, to know it isn't just me thinking that noone thinks is a that my Noah is a miracle- when he was.
ReplyDeleteand the girls are right.. you write so well..you should look into submitting it, and perhaps others
Jane
I agree with the other ladies, this needs to be published Sal. Well said.
ReplyDeletexxx
Hello Sally,
ReplyDeleteThis post is beautiful. Simply beautiful.
You are so right. More needs to be done. I realize you are in Australia, but I don't think that matters. Research should be shared worldwide on the problem of stillbirth. I've been following First Candle at http://www.firstcandle.org/. Currently, First Candle has organized an effort for citizens to push their legislators to support First Candle's efforts to end stillbirth and SIDS. I wrote to mine. I'm wondering if you'd share this post with First Candle and whether they could use it to promote their cause?
Thank you for writing this, Sally.
Peace.
Sometimes given what I now know about miscarriage, infertility, and infant death, I think it's a miracle that we continue as a species.
ReplyDeleteYou're absolutely right though. I also don't get how they can say "miracle" in one sentence (implying some higher authority had a say in the kid's life) and "mom saved the day!" in the next. I think people who use this terminology have a lot of problems with fear and reality and like walking right up to the cliff but then being able to throw it in reverse and have a happy ending. And if there's a happy ending there's no need for outcry and research. Sucks.
Well done, this. You should send it to the papers involved and let them know.
What a beautiful post, I couldn't agree with you more! I hope someday you can write your story on her! She was a miracle and her story should be heard along with all the others.
ReplyDeletebabyparamore.blogspot.com
This is something I've been thinking a lot about lately. When babies don't make it, we're expected to act as though they never existed. We're made to feel like we're outcasts, and that our real life is too disturbing to expose to others. Our little babies were miracles, they were beautiful, they were amazing, and they fought just as hard as the babies that made it. And yet they aren't written about in the news, nobody talks about them, and nobody knows just how common they are. 1/140 is huge. It's time society stopped ignoring us and started caring for us and our miracle babies.
ReplyDeleteAnother thing I've been thinking about is a letter I saw on the internet where some workplace colleagues wanted a woman to take down pictures of her stillborn baby. So many people agreed with these colleagues, and it is just so upsetting to me that people think of our dear babies as anything but beautiful.
Thank you so much for this blog post. It really resonates with me, and I agree with everything you wrote.
I totally understand how you feel. You're right - hindsight is always 20/20, as they say. Fingers crossed for this pregnancy.
ReplyDeleteSally, what a wonderful, power and deeply moving post this is. And yes, it should be an article.
ReplyDeleteI used to always read the biths section in the newspaper. And sometimes I would see the little entries for a birth and a death - a precious still born baby. But as you know, anti-natal classes never mentioned it and the books don't really touch on it. I know why they don't and you know why they don't. Pperhaps if they did 'mention' it we all wouldn't feel alone, missunderstood and wouldn't be treated so insensitively.
Sending love to you all. xxx
you are so right... so very right... they are all miracles and it would be nice if, every now and then, the rest of the world picked up on that too.
ReplyDeleteI couldn't agree more, with everything you've written.
ReplyDeleteI hope someone publishes your article..
Love, Lindsay
I hope you can get this published because every word you said is true. It's seems impossible to raise awareness of stillbirth because no one wants to listen, but an article like this might just open one person's eyes..and maybe one baby doesn't have to die because his/her Mama didn't live in a bubble.
ReplyDeletei cannot handle it when people refer to babies as miracle babies. i want to scream at them, "what, my baby wasn't?" crazy making.
ReplyDeletethis is a powerful post. i am so glad you wrote it.
--mari
THIS should be published. Don't give up - you speak for so many of us and people need to hear this. Thanks for another thoughtful, powerful post.
ReplyDeletexoxo Malou's Mama
I am with you. I do not have any children myself as of yet, but I do have a family member that lost a full-term baby, inexplicably, at birth. Your baby and her baby are not any less of miracles simply because they did not live, all babies are miracles, the odds of conception are actually pretty low, there is really only about a 15-25% chance each cycle, but somehow babies are conceived. I don't like it when people say "well, we were here pulling for her, and she made it through", as if the babies who pass away didn't have people pulling for them or didn't put up a fight. :( I just wish people would be more careful about what they say.
ReplyDelete"They don't want to scare the parents" Read: "they don't want parents fearing that they will be on the wrong side of a 'slim' statistic and freaking out and demanding better care. Best to just risk those few babies for the better management of healthcare."
ReplyDeleteMaybe the newspapers are failing because they don't report worthwhile stories.
And ya know what too, what about all those young, poor girls that don't receive ANY prenatal, don't even know that they are pregnant until really late, and still have live babies (although I won't claim that they are all healthy, I am sure that many have problems)
anyway, i am cranky over here today i guess.
I do hope you find a wide-audience place to publish. Have you tried magazines?
amen, Sally.
ReplyDeletei'm going to bring this to the meeting i have in September with our local hospital foundation regarding their mailing strategies and use of language. they've been receptive and i do hope to see fewer miracle mailouts from them - i think this may help make the case i'm trying to bring to them.
as i learned from my own naive handling of that effort, though, the way to tell the stories of dead babies in the media is to position the speaker as a crazed, grief-stricken Other, who is thus no threat to people's complacent inhabitance of their own good luck.
i wish you courage as you continue to try to change that.
"she is only here because of the sheer determination of her mother" grrr, that makes me mad too. as if we all didn't do everything we possibly could for our babies. that makes it sound as though we are all failures. that we weren't determined enough. pshh.
ReplyDeletei remember my friend's mom telling me about how her baby died when she was as far along as me (when i was about 32 wks) and i remember thinking, why on earth would anybody tell a pregnant woman that?! that's pretty cruel. after all, my midwives and doctors never mentioned it, so it couldn't have possibly been something to worry about, right? again, MAD.
great post, thank you!
Thinking of you- and well said! Our local paper did a nice story featuring our hospital's amazing support group. They focused the story around my son's story- which was the perfect pregnancy- with a not so happy ending... I was shocked by the people that came out of the woodwork. Perhaps that would be the angle to go in getting the story out there- from the blog world alone- you know there is a desire to tell the stories of the forgotten!
ReplyDeleteGod Bless!
Laura D.
Your post struck so many notes for me.
ReplyDeleteI was standing next to a friend the other day when she congratulated another friend on the recent birth of her daughter. 'You've done well' she said. Just something simple really but it made me thing 'and how have I done then?'. Pretty crap obviously. My baby was stillborn when I was 35 weeks pregnant.
The other thing I find horrible is people hearing what went wrong - I had poorly treated obstetric cholestasis - and saying 'oh my friend had that but the doctors put her on some drug and the baby was fine.' Ah that would be the drug I should have been on. Makes me feel terrible.
Or 'we almost lost our baby to pre eclampsya but our obstetrician phoned us to say come in, we need to get the baby out.' Makes me feel worthless.
And the media thing. Even if it saved no babies, it would have been good to not feel like the only woman who had ever had a baby die. No one talks about it. I said to the consultant at our post mortem meeting that the midwives should have told me my condition was serious and he said 'women can't be told'. Great.
Hope was a miracle. And she was your miracle. Created in love and birthed in love.
xx Bec.
Hospital policy is outrageous. How awful! 4 cm? Talk about cookie cutter! I reached 4 cm after 24 hours of insane labor. The next time I was checked after that, I was ready to push.
ReplyDeleteI'm happy I chose home birth for my last baby. The midwife was so much more attentive and didn't leave my side all through labor.
I'm sorry for all your heartbreak. :( I can't even imagine the pain. Your daughter is beautiful in those photos. Just precious. I wish you luck with the upcoming birth of your son!
I am new to your blog i found you through the secret garden.
ReplyDeleteEverything you said is so true. You definantly need to get this published. My situation was a bit diferent to yours, i was classed as high risk because i was having twins, monitored 2 or 3 times a week weekly ultrasounds weekly doctors appointments all on diferent days but because it was a perfect pregnancy noone listened to me when i said that something was wrong and then they were too busy to fit my apointment in so in the 5 day gap where i usualy would have had at least 2 sets of monitoring done i didnt have any and they died from an infection that could have been easily picked up on. If i had of been told about the things that can happen i would have noticed the signs and forced them to do something instead all i was told was that if i didnt go into early labour everything would be ok and stupid me thought that if the doctor says that then it must be true. More people need to know about this.
I also hate it when people talk about miracle babies and how the baby must have had a strong will to live. it makes me feel like they are saying that all the babies that die dont want to live.
thankyou for sharing this
Rikki xxx
What an amazing post. Quite a few years ago, there was an article in my local paper that was about this. It focused on one family, and how the hospital dealt with the loss of their full term baby. Included in the article were pictures of the baby taken after his birth. Essentially the article was about a program run by this hospital to deal with the loss of babies. It was, I believe, the first hospital in Alberta (in Canada) to have such a program. I think all the major hospitals have it now.
ReplyDeleteHaving read that article, I was much more concerned about issues with my final 2 pregnancies than with the ones before...I was so much more aware that things could go wrong. I hope you are able to get something published and raise the same awareness.
I am a frequent reader of Carly's blog and found your blog through hers.
ReplyDeleteI am in tears. Thank you for writing this post. I thank my stars that I happened to meander to your blog this morning. Every word rings true. Since my beautiful, healthy nephew inexplicably died at 41 weeks unbeknownst to us as we drove to the hospital for his scheduled induction, after fighting for days to convince the doctors that for some reason labor just didn't seem to be progressing, and angry now that our only response from them is "don't worry next time there will be lots of monitoring"... I have thought the same thoughts that you wrote about.
Just, thank you for posting this. Bless you and your beautiful angel baby.
I am here via The Creme de la Creme, and I can't tell you how many times I have had this exact same thought. It makes me happy that people derive so much joy from hearing about all of the 'miracle' babies in the world, but it breaks my heart that they aren't hearing about the babies who are 'statistics' and casualties of, well, so many different shortcomings. I have to agree with everyone else in saying that it would thrill me to no end to see this post printed for the non-blogging public. I am so sorry for your loss.
ReplyDeleteWhile I know your blog I found this post on the Creme list.
ReplyDeleteIt's very good, and you are right, people should know that stillbirth happens. It's all the more painful because parents get escorted to the shadows by society when their children die.
Arrived here from the crème de la crème list.
ReplyDeleteI can only feel outrage at the fact that your story is being ignored by the media.
Only reporting happy ending stories makes it all that harder for those who weren't that lucky to bear.
And I feel the urge to shake my fist at the universe for what happened to you. I'm sorry for the loss of your beautiful girl Hope.