Saturday, August 8, 2009

Things we shouldn't say

There are some things that should probably remain unsaid. They are hard to say, and most people in this place never say them. And I know by saying what I'm about to say, I'm going to alienate and piss some people off, but it is how I feel - and I can't change how I feel. I only know what I know. This is the experience I am living - I can't change it and I can't order another one. I don't know it any other way, but what I do know is, what I am living through, is tough.

Not for one second will I say that losing a firstborn baby is worse than losing a later child. But what I will say is, it does make it a very different experience. And difficult. The loss of my child, the loss of my parenthood and at times the complete loss of hope. But I know, they are all different, and they are all difficult experiences. I still find I have far more in common with people than I don't. These losses bring us all together in so many ways.

I have been reading for long enough to know gestation, age or birth order does not change the way we feel about our children. It does not mean we love them any more or less. It does not mean they leave behind a bigger or smaller hole in our hearts. All our babies leave their mark. Their deaths leave us totally and utterly devastated, wondering how on earth we will ever go on.

But for me, and I'm sure I speak for others, losing a firstborn has just changed me to my core. Fundamentally. It broke me in to millions of tiny little pieces, I don't even know where to start in terms of trying to rebuild my life and myself. It was hard to know how I would ever go on, without another child here who needed me. This is why for me, I had to be pregnant again as soon as humanly possible. Because I could not bear to face one extra day on this earth living with completely empty arms. I needed to find purpose in life, and I'm just so damn lucky that the Universe granted me that new pregnancy as quickly as it did, as it has renewed so much of my hope and will to live. That is all that keeps me going these days. The new life inside of me. Without this new baby, I don't like to think about where I'd be now, and I know there are many out there who are living that hellish existence. And for that I'm so sorry.

I am not exactly jealous of others who have older, surviving children. In fact in most cases, if not all, their very existence brings me much joy. And hope. I love reading about them, hearing about their antics and how they fit in to family life when one or more of their siblings is missing. I have always read blogs and stories that feature live children. I always kept reading about mamas who went on to get pregnant again before I did. As much as it was, and sometimes still is, very hard, it did bring me hope. It did give me a lot to chew on, knowing one day I'd probably end up in that same place - the parent of both a live and dead child. I feel I have so much to learn from babyloss mums with kids - both those who came before and after loss - as with any luck, that's where I'll find myself in about three months time. With one foot in both camps.

Obviously I don't know, but can only imagine, parenting after loss would be very, very hard. But this is the thing, when/if I do ever get to parent (a live child, that is) I will always have to parent after loss. I will never know what is like to parent without that dark cloud of loss hanging over my head. I will never get to parent without this heavy grief in my life. I will always wonder what sort of a mother I would have been. This all makes me so sad. I just feel like aside from the death of Hope, I got cheated of so much more. All of those special first experiences. I will hopefully get them again with this boy, but it will never be the same. Those are the experiences I should have had with Hope. I know we love our kids all the same and that love can keep expanding even if we keep on breeding, but there is something special about the first. There just is. Everything is just so lovely and new.

On the flip side I suppose, and I don't deny this for one second, perhaps having lost my firstborn, will make me a better mother. Neurotic and crazy yes, but more present, more grateful and more loving. But again, I don't really know. I'll still always wonder about that mother I was going to be when our Hope got away. The most comforting part for me is, whoever that mother was, is with Hope now. Hope took that Sally with her. When she died, such a large part of me died, too. I hope whatever was left behind is enough to cut it as a mother to a live child. Soon I will know.

A lot of this rant comes from the fact I am terrified I will never have a live child - even now, almost 24 weeks in to a new pregnancy. I am worried they will keep on dying, that I'll only ever bear dead children. I'm terrified I will never get that full, complete experience. The one that goes positive pregnancy test - nine months of bliss - birth - take baby home - live happily ever after. I know it sounds ridiculous, as I'm edging towards the end with this baby, and the odds are stacked heavily in my favour, but it is hard to see the light when death at the end of a pregnancy is all you know. I'm trying to cling on to that hope, that simmers away somewhere below the surface, but it is hard.

It makes me so sad that I don't have any positive experiences or happy endings to fall back on. I have never done this before. 100 per cent of my pregnancies so far (this one excluded) have gone to shit. I can't say to myself "well, despite what has happened, I have done this once/twice/three times before so I know I can do it again". I'm scared of this not working out, because it has never worked out for me before.

What I am grateful for though, and especially in this community, is that most people do make me feel like a mother, when on most days, I find myself questioning that very notion. Some do a very good job of this, and they know who they are and I'm so thankful for them. I still don't always know if I am a mother. I don't know how to mother a dead baby, even though this is exactly what I have been doing for almost 12 months now. I have no other mothering experiences to compare this to. I know people always tell me what I am doing by honouring Hope's life and memory is real mothering, but it doesn't always feel like it. There are no dirty nappies, no cries in the night (mine aside), no vegetables to mash, no toys littering the house. From the outside, there is nothing that resembles motherhood in my life whatsoever. Nothing. Just that empty nursery and a few tasteful photos displayed around the house of the life and child that never was.

I so wish I knew what it was like to give birth to a live child. To have them warm and placed on your chest at birth and to see them stare up at you for the first time. To hear those first cries. To have them want you and need you and love you - like no one else on earth ever could. To strap them in a car seat and bring them home from hospital. To get home, proudly carry them in to the house and show them around, introduce them to the dog. To have the gushing visitors and the "congratulations" cards arrive in the mail. To put them to bed. Watch them sleep. Push them in a pram. Show them off to family and friends. Take photos. Share those photos, without people being afraid of them. Hear them cry. Feed them. Nurture them. Love them. I want all of this so badly and it terrifies me that I could never get it - and I came so damn close with Hope. So devastatingly close. No matter how many children I go on to have, and I know this is true for us all, I will always wish I could have done those things with Hope. All of that, and so, so much more.

And as I mentioned a few days back, without another living child at home, it does make the days seem long, hard and pointless. I know it would still be hard with other children at home (hey, maybe even harder, who am I to say) but there would be more of a reason to go on, get up and face each day. I'm not jealous of others, I just wish I had this for me. And this is the thing, while I feel myself wishing for a different experience and wishing for live children at home, I don't think there would be many out there who would be wishing for this - the double whammy of babyloss and lost and shattered parenthood. It is just too cruel to imagine, yet it is the reality I live with every day. Every long, boring, quiet and empty day. And it is so sad knowing I am not alone. Even more sad knowing there are people out there with greater struggles than me. No living children, no parenthood and no new pregnancy. It is all so unfair and I wish I could change things.

I just wish there was someone out there who could tell me it was all going to be ok. That this baby was going to be born alive and well and come home with us. I wish someone could tell me that, and I wish I could believe them. I wish I could get some sort of iron clad guarantee on this pregnancy. I want to know I'm going to really get to do this motherhood thing. And not this type of motherhood, because as much as it gives me plenty of spare time and allows me to do what I want, when I want, it is simply exhausting.

29 comments:

  1. "I will never know what is like to parent without that dark cloud of loss hanging over my head."

    That hit me really hard. So fucking unfair. I wish I could change things too, Sal.

    Of course, we can't compare two parallel dimensions, one where our children live to this one, but I have to believe that what we do with our losses, how we apply that to our mothering, that our blogs and all this writing and processing will ultimately make us better mothers,more sensitive friends and partner...I hope. With love.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Sally I can't imagine the fear you must feel. And you know I won't try.
    I wrote this on someone elses blog today and I repeat it here.
    To some degree I'm still the little girl who stood helplessly by as her father pushed past her, almost throwing her one month old baby brother on the bed as he tried and failed to revive him from a sleep he was never going to be roused from.
    That experience has coloured my whole life and I wasn't a mother, I was just a big sister. I will say it's made me a better, more appreciative mother. It's made me more tender and thoughtful.
    So I don't know what losing Hope will do for you as a mother to her baby brother, but I do hope and pray that all will be well with this new pregnancy.
    xxxxx

    ReplyDelete
  3. Ok, well I do know what you're talking about here Sal. I know exactly what you're talking about. And you're not alienating me.

    Firstly, it's not ridiculous. Your fear is completely rational. Of course it is. Don't doubt it for a second.

    Secondly, oh yes, it's worth it. Hearing that cry. Seeing that purple, slimy baby is 100% worth it. It's why we go through this. If Kees hadn't been born alive, if he had been stillborn too, I wouldn't be doing this again. But Kees was beautiful. He was perfect. He was everything that I wanted. And that's why I'm doing it again.

    And finally, you are a great mum. And you will be a great mum.

    ReplyDelete
  4. You are a mum - a beautiful mum to Hope...I exactly agree with what Mirne said..I also can so much associate that fear...another baby loss mama said she wished she could go to sleep for the duration of the pg and wake up with a baby in her arms whom is living and breathing... I so want that and I am so wanting that for you too Sallyx

    ReplyDelete
  5. Sally, to my mind we SHOULD say these thing. All of our experiences are so different, and the presence of living children is a major factor in how we experience grief for our lost babies. I value your honesty.

    Even when we can't fully comprehend another's pain, I think it's important for us to recognise that it's there, that they are going something terribly difficult, even if it's outside the realms of our own experience.

    If I've realised anything from reading these blogs, it's how seldom people in the real world behave well in the face of grief, how often they completely lack empathy of any sort. We all have stories about that.

    Yet here, in our world, we seem to strive to see past our differences - living children, pregnant or not, different faiths, different ways of grieving or honouring our children, different backgrounds - and provide love and support for each other.

    So, in other words, carry on saying the unsayable please!

    Lots of love xxxx

    ReplyDelete
  6. Sally, I so wish that I could tell you everything was going to be okay this time.. but I know how I feel when other people assure me of that! Everyone except the doctor seems to be 1000 percent sure that my baby will NOT die again! Of course, the doc thinks it'd be pretty rare too, but he's not handing out guarantees.

    Parenting does change after a loss, and I have been extremely grateful for having a living child. I can only imagine how much worse I would feel if she wasn't here with me.. because of Gwen, I didn't allow myself to go deeper and deeper into my grief. But as with everything else, there are two sides - telling her that her brother was never going to come home was one of the hardest things I ever had to say - and thinking at 2.5 years old, she wouldn't really 'get it' but seeing the way she cried at that news still crushes me.. and now, when talking about the baby in my belly and feeling like I'm lying to her when I say she'll have a sister at home soon.. it just adds to the suck factor.
    I just hope we all get our little rainbow babies to bring home!! :)

    ReplyDelete
  7. Oh how I can relate to so much of what you're talking about here. Thank you for sharing, even when it might be taboo for others to read. There are still so many of us that can relate to your experience and what you're talking about.

    "This is why for me, I had to be pregnant again as soon as humanly possible." Me too.

    "When she died, such a large part of me died, too. I hope whatever was left behind is enough to cut it as a mother to a live child." And I can't even tell you that it gets better, even though I have a healthy baby at home right now. My biggest fear, is that the part of me that died with Dylan is leaving such a gaping hole in the mother that I should be to Faith right now. Am I enough for her and for whatever subsequent children we may have?

    I guess there are just some things that we'll have to survive never really knowing the answers to.

    Kat
    http://indylansmemory.blogspot.com/

    ReplyDelete
  8. I get it Sal and I'm glad you wrote this down. I think people get upset by the way this topic is expressed usually but I didn't see anything that didnt make perfect sense to me in this post.

    You know how I feel Sal. I am so sorry your 'first' experience of mothering a living child will be tainted by the loss of your precious Hope. It has robbed you of a beautiful innocence and replaced it with something 'other'.

    I know you will still have joy and will have much laughter in your life when Thumper arrives but it will always be different.

    People used to say to me when we were facing a lifetime of struggle with Jordan's disability that Caelan would grow up to be a lovely compassionate litte boy... that knowing hardship and pain would make him beautiful and sensitive. This infuriated me as I still felt he'd been robbed of a normal life. Boys are supposed to be carefree and wild...kids are supposed to be selfish and spoiled... and I would prefer that to anything that was wrung out of him through hardship.

    This is what we all want... that normal life... the one we should have had before our babies were ripped from us.

    Ignorance is bliss.

    Thinking of you Sal.
    xx

    ReplyDelete
  9. Funny you should say that. Kevin and I were just musing the other day about how our first, 4-month miscarriage was HARDER than our full-term stillbirth a year later. Isn't that weird? It really just was mentally more of an acid trip gone awry while having a knife through the heart at the same time. I think it's because when you lose that first one, it's your innocence and ignorant bliss that goes away, and that's what you never get back.

    ReplyDelete
  10. You are a mom and a beautiful one at that. And I often wonder what type of parent I will be if I get that chance now - I'm different and not always in a good way. Much love, Sally.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Sally - I'm so appreciative you've shared this.
    The quote that angie quoted brought me to tears Sally. In my selfish grief, I'm not sure I really understood your shoes, the shoes of a mother who has lost her firstborn.

    With so much love, support and hopefulness for you in this pregnancy...

    ReplyDelete
  12. Don't ever feel bad for posting what you feel. I can't imagine giving birth to a stillborn baby.
    I will never know what you know.
    But I do believe and I do pray that when your son is born you will be an excellent mother because you were the perfect mother for Hope. As a mother of two living children I do know that we mother each child in a different way. I can't wait to read your posts after you have your son. Your love for him will be so perfect in every way. He is one lucky little boy!

    ReplyDelete
  13. "But for me, and I'm sure I speak for others, losing a firstborn has just changed me to my core. Fundamentally. It broke me in to millions of tiny little pieces, I don't even know where to start in terms of trying to rebuild my life and myself. It was hard to know how I would ever go on, without another child here who needed me."

    Sally, you've definitely spoken for me with this post. I can relate to so much of what you've written. I feel like we are on very similar paths, only I just set out on this path six weeks ago. I'm absolutely terrified at the thought of another pregnancy and another loss, but I'm more afraid of the thought of never having a living child here with me in my arms. I just have to try again. I have to have hope.

    Since Isla died my husband has remarked several times that he is grateful that we don't have any living children because he can't imagine how difficult it would be to parent after loss and to explain the death of a much anticipated sibling to a young child.

    I found it really interesting that he felt this way, because I have so often thought about how much I'd prefer to have living children - to know what its like to have a happy ending to a pregnancy, to have a living child to love, someone else to live for in these dark hours.

    We concluded that we couldn't know whether it was more difficult to lose a first born or a subsequent child, but that either way it is VERY difficult.

    But I do still wish that I knew what it was like to give birth to a live baby, to hear my baby cry, to hold my baby, nurse my baby, be a mother in the conventional sense. And while I like to believe that I will be a better mother to another living child because of Isla, I also desperately wish I knew what it would be like to be a mother to Isla, my first born, without ever having experienced such grief.

    I will never know the latter, but hopefully, someday, I will know the former - I so desperately hope that all of us mothers will.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I found this particularly sad because I hadn't gotten far enough to think of the fact that I'll never parent a live child without that dark cloud of grief. And I agree that losing your first born sets a terrible precedent for the future. I miss my innocense too. Losing my first born has been a nightmare, but if I had living children to parent everday after that I wouldn't have gotten the chance to fully grieve for Mackenzie. And I probably would have been a shitty mom to any living children for a long time after I lost her. But I agree that it would have given me a reason to get out of bed and keep going. It sucks that any subsequent pregnancy will be filled with fear. Ugh! Anyways, thanks for this post. I will be praying that you get to bring your baby boy home :)

    xo

    ReplyDelete
  15. We open up our hearts and lives out here, and what you give is a gift. Your pain, your fear, all of it, every genuine feeling, is a gift. Thank you for sharing it.

    ReplyDelete
  16. When reading this blog I felt you had read my mind and heart. Every word you have written is exactly how I feel. I lost my first born, Akul and I do not know if I will ever hold a healthy live baby, who comes out of my womb, in my arms.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I agree that you lose your innocence when you lose your first. It does make it harder. Between my miscarriage (a boy), and the birth of my first daughter, was a period of four years. ANd it was scary to try again. I think there is some difference in pain between losing your first and losing a second, third, etc. But they do both suck. I am having trouble now that we are wondering if I am dealing with another miscarriage (and my tubes were tyed after the hard pregnancy with my second daughter) and I have been on the verge of tears all day. I feel WITH you. I wish that I could just wrap my arms around you in a hug and promise you things will turn out exactly the way we are all hoping for you this time. I can't promise it, but I sure can hope and pray it. And maybe my son is up there in heaven playing with your Hope. (and if I just lost one...that one too). ANd now the tears are flowing...

    ReplyDelete
  18. Sally-
    Your honesty in this post is gutrenching. I don't know how many times I have told myself I am so, so lucky to have my kids to get me through this loss. And I have said countless times that I can't imagine not having them and suffering through this. I honestly don't know what I would do. It's hard enough to feel that way now and I have had successful pregnancies. But you should also know that it's blogs like yours and Carly's and so many others on the Water Babies blog that inspire so many of us. We go on because you are going on. We see you doing it, getting pregnant again, being brave enduring the pregnancy, mentally, physically and emotionally....and we know we can do it, too. I think the power to think positive is to be spoken of. Think good thoughts. Of course that could also be a crock but I wouldn't know anything else to do to get me through those nine months. I hope that writing this post made you feel better. It was very honest, very justified and I am with you.....you're gonna do this. I know you are and you are going to be happy. Hang in there and keep your smile, if not for you, for Hope.
    xx,
    Christy

    ReplyDelete
  19. Thank you for being so honest in this post Sally.

    You know that I have said before that any loss is devastating but, that I imagine the loss of a first born has a whole other lot of complexities associated with it.
    Different complexities to those attached loosing a second or third or seventh child.

    I am sad for you that you didn't get to experience your first born in such a different way. Life is really shit sometimes. Really, really shit.

    I am sorry that you will, as you said, now always 'parent after loss.' I am sorry that your baby was taken from you and that you didn't have the chance to mother Hope, here, now and every day.

    xxx

    ReplyDelete
  20. I hear you sally, loud and clear. I always wonder what I would have been like if Hannah had lived. Now, I am just a neurotic mess.

    ReplyDelete
  21. I feel like I could have written this. You said it all perfectly.

    ReplyDelete
  22. I agree with you 200%!!!!!!!!

    Thank you for saying something that is sometimes hard to say. You put it in the perfect words. I'm on my 7th pregnancy...no living children...the HUGE cloud of fear that we will NEVER have ONE child is all-encompassing and compounds the grief. It's not just grieving the loss of a child, but also grieving the ability to ever have one. That is the greatest fear of all for me.

    ReplyDelete
  23. thank you for writing about this. i was just talking to Catherine about this subject. though all of us are going through the pain of losing a child, each of us has a different story, no two the same, but that pain is what bonds us together. it's the glue that holds this sad club together. stupid glue.
    i can't stand it that i have empty arms. i too want a living baby to bring home from the hospital. now. it couldn't happen soon enough. i wish i were pregnant with you! i don't know that i will be the same mother i was hoping to be for Leila, but i know i want to mother again, mother a live baby, no matter how dark that cloud above me is.
    i can't tell you how badly i am wishing that your rainbow baby arrives safe and sound into your arms.

    xo

    ReplyDelete
  24. Sally, you handle these difficult subjects with such grace. And these are things you should say, things you are feeling strongly, and rightfully so. I too wish I could tell you it would all be okay, wish I had the power to change things, to set it all right for you, for all of us.

    I also have often thought how much harder the loss of my daughter would be if I didn't have a living son. At the same time, I agree with Shannon about there being two sides - watching your living child struggle with the loss is so hard. I've been thinking about my experience parenting after loss a lot recently; I just started a blog and I'll probably write a post about it sometime soon.

    I tend to think that my loss is not as bad/difficult as other people's and to feel guilty for feeling as sad as I do. But this post and the other comments have reminded me again that we really can't compare, all our experiences are different but through recognizing that we can have compassion for, and give support to, one another.

    ReplyDelete
  25. I so get how your feeling.
    My dad made a comment years ago to my mother about having your first/only bub die. I find it is so true. While having live children doesnt make any of it easier they do give you a reason to get up in the morning. They force you to live. When its your only child that dies you sometimes just dont have important reasons to get up and function.

    Hugs
    xxx

    ReplyDelete
  26. Heartbreaking Sally. I also lost my firstborn daughter. It hurts so very much, that my first child, the very first child that I gave birth to, died. When I loved her so and had imagined her for years. Perhaps it is because I am the first too, that we were connected in that way. The big sisters of the family.

    Even though my children were born alive, it was a close run thing. I also can't imagine a world where your newborn is handed to you, placed on your chest. Where you get congratulations cards and visitors gush. I really hope that those things lie in my future but who knows.

    And, as you know, in my case it wasn't as simple as that. I had a foot in both camps from the get go.

    There were times in the NICU that I struggled with still having her twin. A baby who seemed unlikely to survive. I didn't want to go back into that same room where her sister had died, not to watch her die too. If she had died it would have been so very, very painful. But not as shocking, not as traumatic as when G died. Before G died, I honestly thought that both my girls would survive. Right up until the moment they declared her dead.

    My mother said to me the other day, kind of in passing, "if J hadn't survived, I think that you would be dead too." I don't know, perhaps.

    I don't know what it is like to parent without loss. Well, I guess I had those three and a bit days. Those days that I will always treasure. But, for nearly a year now, I've been doing them both simultaneously. The vegetable mashing, nappy changing version. The blog writing, weeping, thinking version. They are surprisingly similar I've found. They are about love. That's what drives all of it, sterilising bottles, cleaning up sick, writing words on a computer screen. Love. You are, and you will be, a fantastic mother Sally. You are going to 'cut it.' I know it even if you don't. xx

    ReplyDelete
  27. Despite the fact that I have already left a monstrous comment, I'm back for more. You will have to ban me.

    Just wanted to say how much I loved the idea of the other mother, the mother that is with Hope now. I hope that the mother that I might have been is with my little girl. That happy mother who would have been so much more fun. xx

    ReplyDelete
  28. I don't think losing Curits has made me a better mom... I really don't. I think I would have taken as many photos and cherished each of those moments just like I have with my daughter after his loss.

    But what I think is different is I truly live in the day to day. So many parents think "well..when the baby sleeps through the night, it will be better...when he can walk on his own...when he can feed himself... when he is talking... when he is in school..."

    We never ever have wished time away. Each cold winter day, each sleepless night, we have lived in that moment. I think I would have spent a lot of time when Curtis was tiny "waiting" for the next stage. Now I don't. I take it as it comes. That is one thing I have done well. Enjoyed her at 3 weeks, enjoyed her at 4 months...always taking in each day. Each season.

    ReplyDelete
  29. "I will always have to parent after loss. I will never know what is like to parent without that dark cloud of loss hanging over my head. I will never get to parent without this heavy grief in my life. I will always wonder what sort of a mother I would have been."

    Sadly, this is so very true. This whole post was as though you were speaking my mind. The fear of never parenting a living child is so palpable for me right now, despite being pregnant - I know there are no guarantees. But the loss of the mother I might have been weighs heavy on me too. I miss my boy, I wait and hope for my little girl, and in the meantime everything is coloured with fear and a desperate need to see into the future or be told that this time, it will be ok.

    ReplyDelete

Thank you for stopping by.

 
Design by Small Bird Studios | All Rights Reserved